Written by Amanda Ensor
If you’re a parent, you probably felt seen reading Stephanie H. Murray’s recent piece in The Atlantic, “The School Apps Are Out of Control.” The folder in the backpack. The behavior log to sign. The newsletter, the PTA email, and then the notifications: one app for this child, another for that one, a third that keeps announcing a lunch balance no one owes. If you’re an educator, you may have felt something else. Maybe a little defensive, and probably a little tired. Most teachers didn’t choose five platforms. They inherited them, one well-meaning adoption at a time.
At TalkingPoints, we read the article twice. The first time, we nodded along. The second time, we noticed that its most important finding has very little to do with apps at all. Underneath the frustration with notifications is a deeper problem schools have struggled with long before smartphones: families and teachers aren’t having the conversations that matter most.
Overloaded and Underinformed
Murray’s central insight is that parents are getting both too much and too little information at the same time. Families are flooded with logistics and reminders. Yet, citing Learning Heroes, she notes that nearly nine in ten parents believe their child is at or above grade level in reading, while in most states fewer than half of students actually are.
That gap isn’t a technology failure. It’s a conversation failure. Families hear from schools constantly, but they aren’t hearing the one thing that matters most: Is my child okay, and what can I do to help? Volume is not the same as connection. A school can send fifty messages a month and still leave a family unsure of what’s important, where their child stands, or what to do next.
What the Article Gets Exactly Right
Murray ends with a conclusion we wholeheartedly agree with. The trust needed for hard conversations, she writes, may not be something an app can solve, and the clearest picture of how a child is doing often comes from a real conversation with their teacher.
Yes. Relationships are the work. Decades of family engagement research, from Dr. Karen Mapp’s Dual Capacity-Building Framework to the broader body of work on school-family partnerships, point to the same truth: trust is built through two-way, respectful, ongoing connection, not through announcements.
And that trust has to exist before the hard conversation, not get built in the middle of it. A teacher who has already shared a good day or a reading breakthrough with a family starts a conversation about a concern from a very different place than a teacher making first contact with bad news.
So the question isn’t whether schools should use digital tools to communicate with families. It’s whether those tools are built for broadcasting or for conversation.
Broadcast Tools vs. Conversation Tools
Most of what parents describe in the article is broadcast: one-way messages sent to everyone, about everything, all the time. Broadcast has its place. Snow days and safety alerts need to reach every family fast. But broadcast was never designed to build relationships, and when it becomes the main way schools communicate, families tune out.
One teacher in the article puts it plainly. If she’s concerned about a student, that’s not a conversation she wants to have through a mass-messaging platform. She’s right. A concern about a child’s reading shouldn’t arrive sandwiched between a bake sale reminder and a spirit week flyer.
But here’s the reality many teachers live with. The share of K-8 parents attending parent-teacher conferences has fallen from 77 percent in 2017 to 57 percent today, according to Learning Heroes. Many families work hourly jobs, juggle caregiving, or don’t feel comfortable walking into a school building, especially when the conversation would happen in a language they’re still learning. For those families, waiting for an in-person meeting often means the conversation never happens at all.
That’s the gap TalkingPoints was built to fill. Rather than adding one more app to the pile, TalkingPoints gives teachers and families a simple way to talk with each other directly, in the family’s home language. Schools and districts can also use TalkingPoints for announcements and urgent alerts, but the difference is what it’s built around: two-way conversation, not a one-way feed. Families choose how they connect: by text on the phone they already have, with no download or sign-up required, or through the free TalkingPoints for Families app. A text or message that says, “I’d love to find a time to talk about how Reese’s reading is going. What works for you?” isn’t a substitute for a real conversation. It’s how the real conversation begins.
Starting that conversation well is a skill, and as Learning Heroes founder Bibb Hubbard tells Murray, it’s not one teachers are typically trained for. That’s why TalkingPoints embeds best practices throughout to support building capacity for educators. Our Message Mentor feature, for example, helps by suggesting research-based language that teachers can use, edit, or discard, so a note about a concern opens a door instead of putting a family on the defensive.
The Families Missing from the Conversation
The parents quoted in the article are thoughtful, engaged, and clearly fluent in the language and culture of their children’s schools. And still, they struggle to tell whether their kids are on track.
Now imagine navigating that same flood of messages in a language you’re still learning. Imagine receiving a report on a one-to-four scale with no explanation, or a computer-adaptive test score with no context, translated imperfectly or not at all. For millions of multilingual families, the “too much and too little” problem is doubled, and the conversation that could clear it up is often the hardest one to start.
This is where the national conversation about school communication has to go next. Fixing app overload for some families while leaving others on the outside isn’t progress. Every family deserves clear information and a real relationship with their child’s teacher.
Shifting the Narrative: Fewer Messages, Better Conversations
So what does it look like to get this right? Based on what we see in partner districts every day, a few shifts make the biggest difference.
- From saturation to stratification. Not every message deserves the same urgency. Schools that sort their communication into what’s urgent, what’s important, and what’s nice to know help families find what matters. When everything is a priority, nothing is.
- From broadcast to back-and-forth. The most powerful messages are the ones families can answer. Two-way communication turns a notice into a dialogue and a family into a partner. It’s also something schools can measure. TalkingPoints’ Family Engagement Insights show teachers which families haven’t received a direct message or replied in the past 30 days, and district dashboards show how much communication is one-way versus two-way.
- From grades to clarity. Families want to know where their child stands and how they can help at home. Specific, actionable learning moments shared in a family’s language give families something real to do instead of something vague to worry about. TalkingPoints’ Academics at Home, for example, sends PreK–3 families weekly math and literacy activities by text, aligned to the district’s curriculum. It helps families answer two important questions: What is my child learning? How can I help? And it gives teachers and families something concrete to talk about together.
- From more tools to the right tool. The answer to app overload isn’t adding another app. It’s choosing tools with a clear purpose and asking every platform to earn its place by what it makes possible for families and students.
- From one-size-fits-all to every family. Communication that only works in English, or only for families who can come to school at 3:30 on a Tuesday, isn’t working.
It Was Always About the Conversation
Murray is right that an app can’t build trust on its own. Neither can a folder, a newsletter, or a conference sign-up sheet. People build trust. Teachers and families build it, one honest, caring conversation at a time.
What a good tool can do is remove what gets in the way: the language barrier, the scheduling barrier, the noise that buries what matters. It can make it easier for a teacher to say “I noticed something, can we talk?” and for a parent to say “Yes, and here’s what I’m seeing at home.”
That’s the narrative we want to shift. School communication shouldn’t be measured by how much we send. It should be measured by how well families understand their child’s learning, and how connected they feel to the people helping them grow. We hold ourselves to the same standard. As a nonprofit, we don’t measure success by how many messages move through TalkingPoints. We measure it the way schools do: by whether students do better.
The problem was never the app. It was the conversation. And when we get the conversation right, every family has a place in it.
Family Engagement Month is a reminder that families are a school’s most underutilized superpower. This month, let’s measure communication by the conversations it starts, not the messages it sends.
Learn how TalkingPoints supports family-school partnerships →
Built for conversation, not just communication
TalkingPoints helps PreK-12 districts improve student outcomes through the power of family-school partnership. Our family engagement platform is built around two-way conversation between families and the educators who support their child. Families and educators connect in 150+ languages, by text with no download required or through the free TalkingPoints for Families app. Schools and districts can also send announcements and urgent alerts, but everything we build is designed to improve student outcomes. Independently validated research shows TalkingPoints leads to gains in attendance and academic performance.


